Showing posts with label unemployment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label unemployment. Show all posts

Sunday, February 12, 2012

What is unemployment?

An individual is unemployed if she does not have a job, but she is actively searching for one. The unemployment rate is, therefore, the percentage of the labor force (those who either have a job, or are actively searching for one) who do not have a job; it is determined by means of a survey.

Why does unemployment matter? Consider the textbook model of the labor market. The labor demand schedule (D) relates the quantity of work would-be employers want to buy to the level of wages. The labor supply schedule (S) relates the quantity of work would-be employees want to sell to the level of wages. In equilibrium, the level of wages (P) is determined by the intersection of the labor demand and labor supply schedules. Because employers want to buy more work when the level of wages is lower, the labor demand schedule slopes down. Because employees want to sell more work when the level of wages is higher, the labor supply schedule slopes up:



Suppose that, for whatever reason, the level of wages is too high (in the diagram, higher than P). The quantity of work employees want to sell (the labor force) exceeds the quantity of work employers want to buy (employment). Unemployment, in this model, is the excess supply of labor due to wages being too high. Lower wages increase employer surplus more than they decrease employee surplus--that is, lower wages (provided compensating transfers) can make everyone in the labor market better off. Unemployment thus signals labor market inefficiency.

For the sake of efficiency, then, we want zero unemployment, right? Not quite. In order for dynamic economies to efficiently allocate labor, it is necessary for workers to change jobs from time to time. At every point in time, therefore, some "natural" fraction of the labor force is in between jobs, resulting in a non-zero unemployment rate. Moreover, because the unemployment rate is determined by survey, some individuals outside of the labor force may pretend to be actively searching for a job (for various reasons), further elevating the unemployment rate. The "natural rate of unemployment" is, consequently, thought to be significantly greater than zero.

What causes high unemployment? Demand-side stories cite contracting labor demand in the face of sticky wages. Supply-side stories cite contracting labor supply masquerading as contracting labor demand. Demand deficiencies cause unemployment rates in excess of the natural rate, while supply deficiencies cause the natural rate itself to rise. The mark of demand deficiency is slowing or static wage growth, while the mark of supply deficiency is rising wages.

It is important to correctly identify the cause. To see this, note that if the problem is demand deficiency, a fix for supply deficiency (encouraging workers to seek employment) raises, not lowers, the unemployment rate. If the problem is supply deficiency, a fix for demand deficiency (encouraging firms to hire more workers) does little or nothing to the unemployment rate, but creates other problems (e.g., excess inflation).

So, why is the unemployment rate in the US so high?



Looks to me like slowing or static wage growth since the onset of the recent crisis. Looks to me, therefore, like demand deficiency is the problem. The prescription for lower unemployment rates, then, is more work, not more workers. And the prescription for more work, recall, is greater aggregate demand for US economic output.

Friday, February 3, 2012

It's morning in America

US economy grows 243,000 jobs in the month of January. In other news, Obama is looking to be a safer bet for re-election everyday.

Addendum: I should explain what I think is happening. In part two of my series on the jobs crisis, I said that too-high (cyclical) unemployment is due to interest rates being too high. To be more precise, there is a so-called "natural" rate of interest, which is the interest rate that would equate planned savings and planned investment, keeping aggregate demand on target. Aggregate demand management involves moving the market rate of interest to keep up with movements in the natural rate of interest. The Fed has been keeping its policy rate near zero since late 2008, so why is the (cyclical) employment situation improving? My view is that the natural rate of interest is rising, which effectively makes the Fed's unchanged stance more expansionary than it was previously.

Why is the natural rate of interest rising? Well, folks haven't been spending a whole lot (hence weak aggregate demand). Consumer durables (e.g., cars) only work for so long. At some point, you cannot delay that new car purchase any longer, so, you have to borrow more (more planned investment) and consume more (less planned savings). Together, that makes for a higher natural rate of interest. In other words, when a recession hits, consumers delay a lot of discretionary purchases until they're more comfortable with their financial circumstances, but you can only delay such purchases for so long. This crisis has been going on so long, and Americans are sufficiently impatient, that they're starting to go ahead with those purchases anyway. And that means that the Fed is effectively stimulating aggregate demand more than it was before, even if its interest rate policy is effectively the same (though they have been dragging out the first projected rate hike for some time, so that probably helps, too). If enough people begin to replenish their consumer durables, a self-sustaining recovery may be underway, as long as the Fed doesn't prematurely strangle it. Hence, it's morning in America...I think. (Buy stocks, sell bonds).

P.S. Matt Yglesias agrees with me to an eery extent. In fairness I generally see things the same way he does...

Thursday, February 2, 2012

Issue #1: Unemployment in America, Pt. III

The recipe for a lower unemployment rate, then, is lower interest rates. Why isn't the US government delivering? Well, the Federal Reserve, the central bank of the United States,  which is responsible for setting interest rate policy, lowered its policy rate to essentially zero in late 2008, in response to the bottom falling out of the US economy. But why didn't it lower it some more? Why didn't the Fed go negative?

Suppose you have cash on hand. Your decision is whether to lend it to others or not. The Fed has pushed interest rates below zero. What do you do? I dunno about you, but I'd hang onto my cash. Why? Simple--cash earns (nominal) interest at a rate of precisely 0% per year. Zero sounds pretty bad, but I'd prefer zero to, say, negative three. Thus, if the Fed tries to push its policy rate into negative territory, folks will just hoard their cash, which does nothing for the unemployed.

What, in that case, can the Fed do for the unemployed under these circumstances? The Fed may no longer be able to lower interest rates today, but don't forget about tomorrow. Interest rates won't remain at zero forever, so there is surely a time at which the Fed is expected to raise interest rates. What the Fed can do today is to convince the public that it will not raise interest rates until there is enough aggregate demand to fully employ America's labor force.

Here is a picture of aggregate demand, as measured by nominal gross domestic product (NGDP) over the last decade:



 

Notice that when NGDP plunged, so did employment. Notice also that even though it has stopped plunging, we never caught up with the pre-crisis trend. That's why unemployment has remained so stubbornly high.

What the Fed ought to do is to make a commitment to keep interest rates near 0% until NGDP recovers to its pre-crisis trend level. In short, the solution to high unemployment is NGDP targeting. Think I'm pulling this out of my ass? Here's Goldman motherfucking Sachs. (Note that I was totally on this first--Jan Hatzius, bow to your sensai.)

That, my fellow Americans, is what I would do to put you back to work. Just hang in there for 13 years.

Next up: fossil fuels, deforestation, global warming, etc...

[Earlier posts in this series:

Announcing my bid for the US presidency

Issue #1: Unemployment in America

Issue #1: Unemployment in America, Pt. II

]

Monday, January 30, 2012

Issue #1: Unemployment in America

Suppose that you own and operate a single firm. For whatever reason, it seems that the demand for what your firm produces has declined. Recognizing this, what should you do? Well, if consumers do not want to buy as much of your output as they did before, you should not produce as much output as you did before. There's no profit to be made in producing stuff nobody wants to buy.

Now that you have decided to scale back your output, it occurs to you that you no longer require as many inputs as you once did. Among your many inputs is labor. If you do not require as much labor as you did before, some of your workers must be laid off.

Responding to a fall in demand, therefore, you have in a very small way raised the unemployment rate. Your ex-workers do not have jobs, but continue to actively seek employment. But why has the demand for your firm's output pulled back? Presumably, other firms in the economy have either begun producing the same goods and services more cheaply (due to technological progress, say), or begun producing different goods and services which consumers want more than the goods and services you produce (due to a shift in consumer preferences, say). Whichever is the case, just as the demand for what you produce is falling, the demand for what others produce is rising. Needing to produce more output to meet growing demand, these other firms must draw upon more inputs--in particular, more labor. This raises the demand for labor, offsetting the fall caused by your firm, thereby restoring full employment in relatively short order. The unemployment rate is elevated only slightly, and only briefly.

Suppose instead that the aggregate demand for goods and services produced by the US economy declines. Much like your firm, the economy "recognizes" that the demand for its output has fallen, causing it to scale back production. Just as your firm would do in the course of scaling back production, the economy disemploys many of its inputs--most visibly, labor. The unemployment rate rises as in the previous case.

In contrast to our earlier example, however, a fall in aggregate demand is not offset elsewhere in the economy. Remember that, in this instance, we're talking about the economy as a whole--there is no elsewhere. Does this mean that the unemployment rate will be permanently elevated?

Ideally, no. The reason is that, usually, prices adjust to clear markets. In our first example, the way that the economy signals to the newly unemployed workers to shift out of your declining firm into other expanding firms is by pushing down the wages you offer, while pushing up the wages they offer. Similarly, if the aggregate demand for goods and services produced by the economy declines, this ought to lower wages in general, encouraging firms to hire more workers. And if wages fall far enough, quickly enough, the number of people looking for work but unable to find it will be as low as always. That is, the unemployment rate will quickly return to normal levels.

In reality, however, this does not happen. The reason, in the view of many macroeconomists, is that wages are 'sticky', or 'rigid'. When there is a drop in aggregate demand, instead of wages falling instantaneously, many wages fall rather sluggishly, or in lots of cases not at all. No single theory as to why this is the case commands a consensus, but the evidence in favor of wage stickiness is quite solid. If wages do not fall immediately when aggregate demand falls, then laid off workers will continue to apply for increasingly scarce job opportunities, keeping the unemployment rate elevated in the short run. In the long run, wages will fall far enough to restore the economy to full employment, but as J. M. Keynes famously remarked, "in the long run, we are all dead." A lot of unnecessary suffering is evitable if policymakers properly deploy the instruments at their disposal to stimulate aggregate demand, encouraging the economy to scale up production, which in turn encourages the re-employment of unemployed workers. In my next post, I will explain how best to do just that.

[Earlier posts in this series:

Announcing my bid for the US presidency

]